This weekend I finally decided to pick up the SlingBox after struggling with the lack of a TV in my home office. I’ve been in there a lot lately, working late and have been going nuts without the background noise of TV. I’ve ended up buying silly movies from iTunes. I’ve also gone through my DVD collection several times over. I think I just need background noise after growing up in a house that was never quiet.
So, why the Slingbox? I have a house that’s just about 90 years old. That means no cable in most rooms and no phone jacks. As it is, we have an Ethernet cable running across the floor upstairs to connect my office into the router in the other room. The idea of running a coax cable across the floor isn’t appealing. And yes, we’ve thought about having the house wired. That’s coming, but not for now.
To deal with this, and also to get ESPN and live sports into my office, I started looking into IPTV solutions. There was the open source route with MythTV, but that would require another box with a computer’s power supply. There’s enough power getting drawn by devices in the TV room already. Then there’s Sony’s LocationFree. Their devices don’t have a tuner and need a set-top box to control. I don’t really want to interfere with whatever Heidi might want to watch in the other room, so that was a non-starter. On the other hand, Sony has a PSP player and I own a PSP. On the other hand, the Slingbox has a version that has a coax in and has an analog tuner built in, so that’s the one I ended up going with, especially after reading reviews.
So far, it’s been great. The viewer is a bit of a CPU hog (probably because the stream is encrypted) and the box runs very hot, but those are my biggest complaints. Setup was a breeze, installation was painless, and I had TV on my computer within 15 minutes of opening the box. That includes wiring it all up (granted, I’m pretty good around my AV gear).
I wondered a while back whether it would run on a G4 Mac. While it takes up 50% CPU on my dual core Intel-based Mac, Heidi’s 1.25Ghz eMac kept skipping and pausing trying to play the video. Again, the encryption was probably to blame. On my iMac, I can program, run Eclipse, do whatever with minimal impact on the video.
If you look closely at the screenshot of the player, you’ll see what it looks like in it’s smallest mode. It’s tight. Click one button and a remote control pops up where you can punch in any channel. Quick channel buttons are included right at the bottom, and clicking the little inverted triangle to the right exposes more presets. The most important feature, though, is the “Always on Top” option, something that too many players forget (I’m looking at you, iTunes!).
You also may notice the bit rate on the bottom right of the picture. Yes, that’s 6 Megabits, really. I don’t think I’ve ever had that much sustained bandwidth flowing across my home network. Good thing I’m upgrading to Gigabit at home right now. (OK, Gigabit won’t improve anything, but it sounds good, doesn’t it? Don’t tell my wife…).
The one feature I haven’t had a chance to test is the remote viewing. Slingbox apparently allows me to watch TV across the Internet, even on some mobile devices. I had some trouble with getting this set up with my router (some UPnP issues for the geeks) so no joy yet. Seems like these network apps are still problematic, and it’s not just limited to the Slingbox. The key feature, not obvious unless you’re a techy, is that the player and the box are adjusting the bit rate dynamically based on connection quality. That feature alone enables Internet viewing of this video. It’s pretty much a must have for a consumer device.
Overall, after the first few days of actual use I’m really happy with the purchase. I recommend the device if you’re looking for TV over your home network.
A small side note: I’m out of network ports in my living room. Basically, I have 4 ports on the router. One goes to my office (where there’s another 5 port switch), one goes to Heidi’s office, and the Tivo and XBox360 take up the other ports. I’ve had to disconnect the PS2 (no major loss). So, right now the Slingbox is plugged into the switch in my office with another cable running across the floor. Needless to say, the 8-port GigE switch is on the way from Amazon.






February 20th, 2007 at 7:42 am
Congrats and welcome to a new world! Betsy and I got a Slingbox (her request) for the wedding, and we couldn’t be happier. She watches from the office whenever she wants. And at night, I put on the game on my computer, while whatever show is on the big screen.
We chose not to use the analog cable input, but rather give it control over the bedroom set-top box. So she can DVR ahead of time during the day, if she wants to have (our favorite) CSI/Law and Order/etc shows at the ready.
I’m surprised you talked a lot about ethernet and not about wifi. The Slingbox needs an ethernet port, but runs perfectly over 802.11g. And we’re in a heavily interfered-with apartment building. (I’ve totally got to replace our 2.4 GHz phone)
February 20th, 2007 at 11:36 am
The problem with wifi is that it takes up more CPU resources. It’s another layer of encryption to decrypt. On my Powerbook (a 1Ghz G4), I can see sustained 40% CPU usage by the system during large file downloads. It’s annoying. I know my new iMac will do better, but I want as much CPU horsepower left over for my development tools.
After all, I wouldn’t need the slingbox if I wasn’t programming in my office.
BTW, does your slingbox run hot? Mine is almost too hot too hold after a few hours of fewing.
Oh, and I’m so tempted to plug one in at work… out internal cable system here gets every major sporting event in the country (and many from the world)… imagine having that feed at home.
I don’t want to get fired, though, so it probably won’t happen…
February 20th, 2007 at 4:04 pm
In the last five years, you and I have developed strikingly different computer usage patterns!
I wouldn’t notice 20% swing one way or the other, since my complex financial models are all set to “Calculate when I’m good and ready” and then I go for some water. It’s like compiling assembly on a 286: all you’re doing is adding and multiplying, but for some reason, when you do a lot of it, it takes forever!
I have no idea whether the box gets hot. It lives on top of my Tivo in the TV stand, and I’d never think to touch it.
Just touched it. It’s warm. I could imagine it getting hot.
February 21st, 2007 at 3:48 pm
Can you download shows via the Slingbox, or at least setup some insanely large buffer for when you’re remote and know your connection isn’t that great?
February 21st, 2007 at 8:25 pm
The video stream is encrypted which defeats the only known recording solution for the Slingbox. It does detect connection speed and claims to even work on certain smartphones (I don’t have one, can’t test it).
May 11th, 2007 at 6:49 pm
Personally, while the Slingbox itself has a lot of promise - the support is atrocious. The phone support techs are laughable - they don’t understand how the product works and how to configure it!