As Tamar eagerly awaits the arrival of her MacBook, we (I) am faced with an interesting question: How best to run XP on it.
For Tamar this is a less important question as she can probably ignore Windows (as she has happily done since she got her first Mac at birth). I, however, have to use XP for certain applications. Currently I’m crawling around with VPC, so any of the solutions are an improvement, however the question is which one to use. Both have advantages and disadvantages. Since an XP license isn’t cheap, running both isn’t really an option.
So the question is, Parallels vs Boot Camp?
Parallels has two major advantages: 1) Fast Booting and 2) The ability to have XP and Mac OS running at the same time (as I do with VPC right now).
There are also some minor advantages, such as not partitioning the hard disk.
The major Con is that there is no direct access to the video card. This will limit PC gaming (and I may lose one of the function that I want to have but currently don’t with VPC). The Parrallels GUI is a bit sluggish, which won’t matter for work, but will matter for fun.
Neither support iSight, but I suspect Apple will fix that with the final release.
I guess the answer should be clear, but I’m still stuck on the video card problem. Parallels seems almost ideal…but not quite. Oh yes, and Tamar keeps say, “If I have to infect my computer with Windows, it better run games.” More to follow…






June 27th, 2006 at 9:52 pm
Same situation, same problem. School’s probably going to throw the occasional Windows-only app at me, and I’d like to play games. BUT I don’t want to give up 10+GB for a BootCamp partition.
Still so unclear.
Oh heck, as soon as I find a game I REALLY want to play, I’ll end up reformatting the drive to install Bootcamp!
June 27th, 2006 at 10:19 pm
Yeah, I’ve heard of this problem before. A friend of ours (Joel, for those who know him) went with Parallel. He couldn’t stop talking about it.
When I get my new computer (before school), I’m probably going to go with the Boot Camp option. I don’t need to have them both running at the same time, so I’m fine with running Windows alone, then rebooting back to the Mac OS when I want to. (Plus, again, that games thing)
June 27th, 2006 at 11:32 pm
Oh, and here’s a link to David Pogue’s review:
http://pogue.blogs.nytimes.com/?p=76
June 28th, 2006 at 8:14 am
I’m really torn here, because I expect to need Windows in very short bursts (some school-related incompatibility) where running both simultaneously will be a huge help.
But I also expect to end up with a game or two that really does need full control.