But this new “customer centricity” overhaul of Best Buy stores really bugs me. As you may have heard, Best Buy is overhauling it’s stores to focus on five “prototypical” consumers:
“Jill,” a busy suburban mom; “Buzz,” a focused, active younger male; “Ray,” a family man who likes his technology practical; “BB4B” (short for Best Buy for Business), a small employer; and “Barry,” an affluent professional male who’s likely to drop tens of thousands of dollars on a home theater system.
Notice, however, that out of the five “protypical” Best Buy consumers, only one is female - the “suburban mom.” Never mind the fact that according to various studies “women spend $50 billion and buy almost half of all electronic goods sold in the U.S. ” (And I’m willing to bet that not all of those women are married soccer moms.)
The Washington Post article on this initiative has an even more stereotypical discussion of “Jill”:
The woman was a “Jill,” code name for a soccer-mom type who is the main shopper for the family but usually avoids electronics stores. She is well-educated and usually very confident, but she is intimidated by the products at Best Buy and the store clerks who spout words like gigabytes and megapixels.
“She’s very smart and affluent,” said Best Buy employee Jenn Metzger.
“Jill is a decision maker. She is the CEO of the household,” said Tony Sagastume, the general manager for the Santa Rosa Best Buy.
“Jill’s children are the most important thing in her life,” Bryant added.
So what about unmarried, affluent, female professionals? Especially those of us who don’t want to be condescended to by a sales clerk in pastel, against a background of awful Mariah Carey and James Taylor songs? Am I supposed to be a “Barry”? I guess that Best Buy just doesn’t want my money. So maybe I should find someone who does.





August 19th, 2005 at 10:57 am
I finally read the links in your post and am kind of bummed about one thing I read. It looks like it’s going to only have one or two primary focuses per store. In other words, I could get stuck with the Best Buy by my house becoming a Jill store (heaven knows CT has it’s share of SUV driving house wives) or worse yet, a Barry store. Because of our wedding and the new roof and chimneys, I’m more of a Ray man right now.
August 19th, 2005 at 11:20 am
Yeah, but what about those of us who don’t fit into *any* of the stores? I would hatehatehate a “Jill” store, but would likely be completely ignored at a “Barry” or “Buzz” store. Nevermind the fact that in the next two years, I have a *long* list of electronic purchases that will need to be made. Makes me wish there were full-sized Circuit City stores up here.
August 19th, 2005 at 12:02 pm
well, for what it’s worth it just seems like the stores will have an enhanced section and the enhanced section has to do with what type of store it is.
And let’s not kid ourselves… the help you get from the Best Buy employees is hit or miss anyway. It probably won’t have any real impact on you in a practical sense.
August 19th, 2005 at 12:12 pm
Yeah, except for the “express lines” that you can only find by having someone escort you. Which seems ripe for abuse.
September 9th, 2005 at 9:23 pm
I am a Personal Shopping Assistant for Best Buy. I am the one who wears the “condescending” pastel blue shirt.
The customer centristic idea is not meant to have the kind of impact I’ve read here. There originally over 15 different “buying groups” who walk into best buy. A bunch of nerds in their nerdery narrowed those 15 down to the most profitable five.
What you read on the internet and in the newspaper is correct, to a point. We do fashion to the sense of the soccer mom but a “Jill” is not necessarily THAT.The Pesonal Shopping Assistant(PSA) program is catered to women in general. BBY has noticed that certain women don’t like coming into the store so we decided to work to get those women to come in the store.
So what about the women there now? Go talk to a PSA. They’ll help you, I promise. Eventhough you don’t “fit the picture,” for lack of better terms.
These buying groups are to target certain types of individuals, the rest of you are welcome to use the services of the segments. That’s what they’re there for. If you don’t want to use them, just talk to a typical sales specialist. It’s your choice. You should always get help at best buy.
September 22nd, 2005 at 12:07 am
I am a Jill Segment Supervisor and have been with Best Buy for 2 years. I have to say that I am extatic about the changes happening in Best Buy. I think it is about time that women are no longer ignored. There are so many electronic companies that give no credit at all to women who “do” know a thing or two about what they want. Please don’t miss understand that Best Buy is not trying to be condesending or insinuate that women don’t know what’s hot in electronics.
When I actually went in to interview for the Supervisor possition and there first question was “who is Jill?” I told them that I took personal offense to what they were classifying a Jill as. A married soccer mom type. I have successfully raised 2 boys by myself and ran several business while doing so.
One of my favorite places to work of all times was Nordstrom. I loved having the ability to take all the time in the world to get to know my customers and build a relationship.
Despite the old philosophy of selling products at Best Buy, even when I first began there, I never could bring myself to let go of the customer relationship way of thinking. When I would see a women standing 10 feet or better away from digital cameras and the like wishing and longing to learn more and afraid to ask stupid questions. I made it a mission to help them leave with a better understanding and not always with product.
What we do as PSA’s is to help, assist, answer questions and inform. And best of all, we are fully given freedom to spend all the time it takes to make customers, all customers feel better about their Best Buy shopping experience.
We do not limit our assistance to women with children, we help anyone that would like a helper that is free to roam the entire store with them.
The emphasis is on the women that currently don’t shop there because they are intimidated with electronics in general.
Making this kind of massive nation wide change is a process. We have some stores now that are considered “kitchen sink” stores. They contain everyone of the segments. The hope is that one day all of the employees at all stores will be personal shoppers to a degree.
Personal shoppers are trained in every department in the store.
Again that kind of massive change is a process.
Please be patient with us and give us a chance. We just want to help.
September 27th, 2005 at 1:09 am
I love reading these posts sometimes and it almost makes me laugh. Here is the thing Best Buy for years was a product centric type of company so basically what they focused on was selling a product, the focus was REVENUE REVENUE and more REVENUE. If you really think about it that is the driving force behind any buisness, how to make more money. Best Buy, however, is taking a completly different approach. I was recently promoted to a full time PSA II as our store began to roll out centricity and as I go through training I am beginning to see that the entire focus has shifted from selling a product to buying a customer. BBY is investing MILLIONS in order to revamp, retrain and reorganize its employees and buisness methods. Best Buy now offers higher end products that it has NEVER offered before. Instead of playing Jurassic park on a tv we now play Ice Age or the Incredibles to give the kids something to do while Mom and Dad shop. The Personal Shopping Assistants are there to inform you, answer your questions and be your lifeline to technology. We are not there to batter Soccer-mom’s into doing buisness with us we are there to make sure no one has to go hunt down an employee or wait 20 minutes to be helped but instead of having to come to the store to have a question answered can call a direct line to that persons assocaite and get an immediate response. Not only that but if the customer does have to come pick something up we can wrap it up in a cart and have it ready and waiting for the customer. Very cool thing to have and heres the catch, it is a free service. Yeah you do not have to pay an additional dime penny or nickle to have the service all you have to do is have an intrest.
Now as far as Jill is concerned. This persona has been sterotyped as a soccer mom but guess what, she really is not. This persona is charcterized as a mother of 1 to several children and either single or married. This person usually works a full time job and her kids are usually very active with scouts, sports or even school plays. What are two things you probably hate about best buy? The loud noise, and the clutter right? If you don’t you may not be a “JIll” customer cause she hates our setup as it was. The idea with the PSA service is to offer this full time professional and mother a convienent and easy service in order to make sure her time is not spent in a line waiting for a cash register or chasing employees down all over the store we are there to make sure she can get to her kids to be picked up from practice on time. To be honest with you I am estatic about this new service and beleive me if you doubt me try it just once I promise you will understand why it has worked.
October 20th, 2005 at 5:53 pm
well…I think you are being a bit myopic…probably on purpose. Each segment has sub segments…they cover pretty much everything you could think of within reason. Jill has the MOST sub-segments.
October 24th, 2007 at 11:22 pm
I am a PSA 2 and i absolutely helping a customer who comes in scared of technology and leaves with knowledge of what was purchased or what will be purchased in the future. And because BBY has taken this approach, it will bring back Jill segmented customers. This is a plus for our business as well as our customers. Also just to clear up the mess, PSA’s will help anyone, not just JILL!